UCSB Anthropology Brown Bag Lecture Series Presents:
Anthropology and the Making of Chumash Tradition
By Brian Haley
Research on the sacred place of Point Conception reveals the role of
outsiders in creating contemporary Chumash identity and equipping it with
the traditions it needs to appear authentic to the public. Among the
outsiders involved in this creation, anthropologists have played one of
the most crucial roles of all. Those involved are mostly archaeologists
and ethnohistorians who have based their actions on a Spicerian model of
assimilation vs. persistence, unaware of the sweeping revisions of
ethnicity and tradition in ethnology and history. This case exemplifies
one way in which anthropology can have unintended consequences,
particularly where the past is studied alongside people who claim it as
heritage. Anthropology's unfinished business lies in coming to grips
with the ethical dilemmas posed by these uses of its product. This will
be the extended dance-mix version of our (with Larry Wilcoxon)
controversial paper presented earlier this month at the Society for
California Archaeology meetings.